6 Comments
User's avatar
Overweening Generalist's avatar

Thank you, Dr. Markolin, for this. As an oldster Humanities kinda guy, I've been interested in science since age 7. During the 1970s I became convinced that that the advent of Modern Science (17th c.) has done far more to make the world a better place than any other area of intellectual thought. Furthermore, it drives economics and real wealth. To see a group of know-nothing clowns and chumps attack it from all sides by "hacking" mass psychology is a daily horror that, speaking candidly, I tend to turn away from because the stupidity is so withering. I retreat to my study.

But I will be writing about this. I am your ally. And I'll no doubt be using some of the richness you present here when I do so.

Thanks again!

Philipp Markolin, PhD's avatar

Thank you for this!

JMirrer MD's avatar

This was a great article! Whether it’s an intentional playbook, or merely a way for social media posters to gain artificial accolades it unfortunately leads to the same place, undermining scientific endeavor.

Your writing reminds me a lot of what Yuval Harari has written about information systems.

Bob Hirshon's avatar

Thank you so much for this! What a great overview! It's a must-read for every scientist, science society and concerned layperson. I've been fighting this battle for quite a while and very much appreciate your efforts.

Bob Hirshon's avatar

And to your point about anti science efforts, maybe my tongue in cheek report on the National Academy of Sciences “State of the Sciences” address here in Washington would interest you? https://bobhirshon.substack.com/p/bobs-state-of-the-science-address?r=16pqo3&utm_medium=ios

Tommy Cleary's avatar

Democracy is important.

It is difficult to listen, but even scientists should.

When we are self congratulatory and weird then there are societal factors that can and will tell us to slow down or even stop.

Some of those arguments can be dismissed, but not all.

Because science is important, but so is democracy.

https://conference.demy-colton.com/be-prepared-for-the-next-pandemic-covid-19-insights